5 Board Games We Disagree On | Discussion | More Board Games! - cutlassboardgame.com

5 Board Games We Disagree On | Discussion | More Board Games!

Foster the Meeple
Views: 1935
Like: 148
Welcome to Foster the Meeple, a channel dedicated to board games and all board gamey things! Join us as we discuss 5 more games we disagree on!
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
If you like what you see, please Subscribe for more board game related content!

Join our Discord:

If you really like what you see, consider supporting us on Patreon:

We have merch! Check it out:

TipJar:
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Jump:

00:00 – Intro

Wrap Up
A Little Bit Extra
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Follow Us on Social Media

Instagram: @fosterthemeeple
Twitter: @fosterthemeeple
Facebook: facebook.com/fosterthemeeple

Contact us for collabs and partnerships
Email: [email protected]
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Do you live in Halifax/Nova Scotia? Check out The Boardroom Game Cafe: (1256 Barrington St, Halifax)

The Board Room Game Cafe is the first cafe of its kind in the Maritimes! Located on Barrington St in Halifax. Featuring a large Board Gaming area with a collection of 600+ games to play (teachers included!), The Board Room is a unique experience with espresso drinks, local craft beer and soda, tasty sandwiches, snacks and an extensive retail area.

Or shop online:
Instagram/Twitter @theboardroomgc

Do you live outside of Halifax? Try Zatu!

Zatu Games is the UK’s favourite and most affordable online games retailer… ready to change the game! Zatu Games has thousands of games to choose from across all genres, there really is a game for everyone!
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Channel Art by: Rowan Allcorn:
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
#boardgames #tabletopgames #boardgamereview #fosterthemeeple

64 Comments

  1. To the cool guy playing Cthulhu with you in the Bills sweatshirt shirt…….Go Bills! Don’t worry, your cool shirt/sweatshirts are awesome too😉.

  2. Ketchup chip sighting during the Cthulhu Death May Die Game!!! 🙂

  3. 4-1 Team Jamie! I haven’t played them but I don’t think I would enjoy Baseball or AgricoBlah. C:DMD is at the top of my must-buy list though. Also, Jeff needs to watch Friends!!

  4. LOL. I did "You Make My Dreams" for karaoke. I like that song a lot.

  5. Wow Jamie went SPICY with those Agricola takes. As a newer gamer I was so excited to learn Agricola and enjoyed it for the first time. And I also like New York Zoo haha I haven’t played enough games to hate any 😅

  6. Cthulu:DMD is one that I really, really, want. Was able to get a deal on Mansions of Madness, so hoping that will scratch that itch for now. Great vid guys!

  7. Agricola B&S just felt like a game about feeding penalties and it sounds like it's not going to hit any differently than its parent game for you 😬

  8. I hated Agricola the first time I played it. After a year in between plays and as my gaming tastes have changed I have fallen in love with this game. This game does so many good things that far surpass a lot of newer worker placement games or euros. The theme, the right gameplay, the tough decisions, the player interaction it’s awesome! Agree with you Jeff 100%!

  9. Gameplay wise Cthulhu DmD is fine, but functionality wise its like miniature over congestion the board game. I have had 8 miniatures on a 1×1 tile. Also, the timing of the discovery cards can also be so wrong that the game swings totally the other way.

  10. I don't watch playthroughs much (other than occasionally if I need to learn a game), but these sorts of videos makes me think I need to see you two play Decorum together – it would be hilarious!

  11. I’m pretty sure that playing between two castles of mad king Ludwig where you just play on your own board is just castles of mad king Ludwig.

  12. Baseball Highlights is wonderful. I’ve purchased a few expansions from Eagle Griffin and it’s a super fun package now.

  13. Love Raspoutine! Please tell me there is also a Nanaimo Barbara.

  14. Both wrong. Caverna with Forgotten Folk is best Agricola.

  15. I've never played Baseball Highlights 2045 but it always reminds me of Base Wars for Nintendo. In that you can upgrade your robot players, and every force play is a melee battle between the runner and the fielder: survivor takes the base. It was one of my 2 favorite baseball video games, along with Baseball Simulator 1.000. Probably before your time, you young'uns.

  16. Maybe its a cultural thing but I have never heard anyone describe standard base running in baseball as confusing. Although I suppose I would have the same reaction trying to understand cricket. Jeff, it you really want to confuse Jamie start bringing up taking large leads, tagging the base, stealing, breaking up double plays and designated runners. I laughed out loud during the extra part where she freezes and stares menacingly at those darn dirt bikers! I have seen this reaction in other videos and even though moving is a pain, you will at least be getting away from that nuisance.

  17. So agree on Mysterium! Last time we played I (Libby) gave excellent clues, Julian was so far from getting them though, he even posted on socials to 'prove' there was no way he could have guessed it!! Interestingly the picture he took asking for comments was missing one of the clues! So I'm sticking to the i'm an excellent clue giver theory hahaha 🤣🤣

  18. Is it possible to agree with both of you, er, or disagree with both of you?

  19. Sorry Jeff but baseball highlights is confusing! 🙂

  20. Death may die has not only climb up my top ten but even those lost of my gaming groups both guys and gals alike, I didn’t mean to sound like Santa clause there. So much fun, even better that it is all painted, have taught it to many new gamers to suck them in. Always a hit. Never have anyone getting crabby even if they get knocked out first. Let’s be honest, Once one goes, the rest will follow shortly. Or….one epic massive dice roll for lethal tentacle damage!

  21. Play Dixit and Castles of Mad King Ludwig. Dixit is great with a bigger group. Castles is one of our “tried and true” games. One the table a fe2 times a year. I think Jeff will like those much better. Less talking. 😂 Good topic for a future video.

  22. On this one i'm in team Jamie ! Mysterium is a great family game and i don't understand why people like Agricola so much. I would really like to try Between two castle !

  23. J-E-F-F Jeff Jeff JEEEFFFFF! Up up UP with JEFF! down down down with Jamie …

  24. We love all your videos especially your Villainous ones! Do you plan to get the Target edition with Syndrome, Madam Mim and Lotso?

  25. I don't care for Castles of Mad King Ludwig and I don't care for Between Two Cities.

    Agricola is a mess, but it gave us Caverna which is amazing.

  26. Grabbing my popcorn, any excuse to watch you both bicker! 😆

  27. Now I'm curious to play those games to make my own opinion 🙂 already got Mysterium and was eager to play it but now I fear I might be the guy giving the stupidest clues haha. Pray that I'm not the ghost.
    Also Agricola, I kinda love the theme.

  28. I think I like Obscurio more than Mysterium…I loved Mysterium, but I recently played Obscurio and I think I prefer it, especially with a group!

  29. I agree with Jeff on Baseball Highlights and my wife will NEVER play it with me!! And it’s one of my favorite games. And I wish the app was better! But hey I also agree with Jamie on Mysterium, love playing and introducing it to people! Great video/banter guys 🫶🏻

  30. I am definitely with Jamie on Agricola. It’s a clever but tedious game about trying to survive as a subsistence farmer which, if what happens to you in the game is anything to go by, seems like it would be depressing as hell, and the feeding your family part is just so frustrating it made me almost want to cry. I played it once, was coerced into playing it a second time and will never do so again.

  31. I've been binge watching your channel recently, as the hobby has been snowballing into a little madness on my end. You guys are great!
    However, no better time than a video about differing opinions to say my piece…
    Spirit Island. That's all.
    Keep up the great work!

  32. Great video! Jeff show some more miniature paintings please.

  33. I love Jamie's spiteful yawns during Jeff's takes on games. Not sure if it they are revenge yawns for Jeff's previous yawning in videos, or is just that bored with Jeff's takes. Either way, top notch! 👍

  34. I am literaly laughing out loud about Jamie's Agricobla! You guys are so fun to watch. I think I would agree with Jamie. But I haven't played many of the games mentioned.

  35. The chemistry between you two is hilarious. It makes your videos so much fun to watch. I love your humor! Whatever that means coming from a German. (Agricola FTW!)

  36. Aggricola uses up my brain power way before its ower. Recently played Hallertau. As an Agricola-esque game it made me consider suffering through Agriccola one more time to see if I hav echanged my mind, because Hallertau was similar and actually fun for me. My oldest friend loves agricola, but he does have other people to play it with.

  37. UUUUsually I'm team Jeff when it comes to board games, but I'm so on board with Jamie on Agricola…it's like feast for Odin…Jamie nailed it…I play games to escape for a little while..farming is a hard life even nowadays let alone the middle ages..how on earth does anyone translate that into a good time? Speaking of translation, someone's going to have to explain the Death may Die thing title to me. It seems like a bad translation from Japanese or something. What does Death may Die even mean? The cover art for Baseball 2045 looks very unappealing to me, but Jeff, you made it sound quite intriguing…well done video as always gang!

  38. HA! I just imagined a scenario when I would play solo Mysterium and still accuse myself of giving stupid clues.

  39. Finally picked up Fantasy Realms on prime day after hearing you guys talk about it all the time. You were definitely right! Such a great little game

  40. i get confused about baseball highlights too

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.