The perfect 20 game collection - cutlassboardgame.com

The perfect 20 game collection

3 Minute Board Games
Views: 8683
Like: 569
A friendly reminder that only our reviews are 3 minutes long

The perfect 20 game collection

To support us on Patreon please head over here

Our website is here:
And, if you just want to buy us a coffee for a good job, pop over here

3 minute board games theme Music by Vic Granell

“Black vortex” “Shiny tech” “Shiny tech 2” “special spotlight” “werq” “Cheery monday” “killers” “crusade” “devestation and revenge” “failing defence” “hard boiled” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License

“Copyright Disclaimer: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act
1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.”

Sound effects from

3 minute board games are J Carmichael and S Rodgers

223 Comments

  1. Do you play dune with the advanced rules? I haven't tried them yet.

    In the same realm, I found it interesting that you considered eclipse as being an event game that was ruled out by dune. I've found eclipse to be really accessible to a wide variety of people, and my group plays it regularly because of this. It's also pretty short and keeps a constant pace once you've played a couple of times. It's our most played game, just edging out spirit island.

  2. Me: oh wow! what an insane challenge! Oh wait I only own like 30 games to begin with. My exposure to board game YouTubers is warping my perception lol

  3. Can I just say how much we adore your content? Lots of love to you!

  4. Anything related to Star Wars or Space is an instant pass for me. The Crew was one of the worst gaming experiences I've ever had .. winning on the first turn for the first 5 missions or so.. nobody wanted to keep playing. Frosthaven is my favorite game.

  5. I love you but you eliminated Cosmic Encounter. How….Dare…You!

  6. Superb video, very enjoyable. Would have also appreciated your suggested best player count for each game.

  7. Thought you were going to pick magic the gathering just out of sheer complexity and card pool

  8. Great List Jay and one that is really hard to do. I loved you giving Tyrants of the Underdark the last spot. Nice Deckbuilder choice. It's a great game. I have the original. There's a lot of crossover with a list I did recently for my patrons, 25 Necessary Games, as a diversion from the ordinary (geopolitics, finance). Since I talk about my board game hobby a lot there was honest interest from some people thinking about trying out the hobby. I made them both a "10 games to start with list" as well.

    That list was more of the… 25 games you should expose yourself to to find out what you really like. There are games on this list I don't like, Sprit Island, Puerto Rico, CE, Terra Mystica are the examples.

    That list is:
    Brass Birmingham

    Dune

    Concordia

    Castles of Burgundy

    Advanced Civilization

    El Grande

    Agricola

    Terra Mystica

    Spirit Island

    Tikal

    Five Tribes

    Orleans

    Puerto Rico

    Any variation on Race for the Galaxy (inc. and preferably Terraforming Mars:AE)

    Power Grid

    Star Realms

    Cosmic Encounter

    Smallworld

    Star Wars: Rebellion

    Dune Imperium

    Blood Rage

    Medici

    Hansa Teutonica

    Sleeping Gods

    Imperial

    I now have to make this list for myself. It will suck to do, as I'm sure yours was.

    For my dungeon crawler I would have also picked Imp. Assault (since I owned a metric shed ton of it) but I had to sell it when I, frankly, needed the money. I'd probably go with my favorite TT RPG TORG: Eternity. But for a strict boardgame the only two I own now are Too Many Bones and one of the Hexplore Its… and Hexplore It is really good. I'd likely keep that over TMB simply because the rules overhead is lighter, there are campaign books to make it more of a TT RPG, and you can put a game together in 3 hours.

  9. 20 is still alot how about 10
    1. Veiled fate
    2. Everdell
    3. Nemesis
    4. Cthulhu death may die
    5. Betrayal at the house on the hill 3rd edition
    6. Bloodrage
    7. Blood on the clocktower
    8. Catan
    9. Dune Imperium
    10. Terraforming mars

  10. Let me know when the garage sale for all the cut games is going to happen 😂

  11. I think the problem for me is when I have too many games, the more I have the less I seem to play them, especially miniature games as I want to paint them, I have streamlined my games down to about 40 games, it just gets to much owning more than that, not only for space, but to much choice, I recently sold off some brilliant games I really wanted to own, but just haven't played them.

    My top 20 games would be and in no order.

    1. Final girl.
    2. Etherfields
    3. Heroquest
    4. Tainted grail.
    5. ISS Vanguard
    6. Zombicide black plague.
    7. The great war.
    8. Mirza Noctis
    9. Arkham Horror LCG
    10. Marvel Champions
    11. Grind house
    12. Mansions of madness
    13. Massive Darkness
    14. Dark Rituals
    15. The everrain
    16. Nemesis
    17. Death may Die
    18. Space Hulk
    19. Battle cry
    20. Descent legends of the dark.

  12. Ok….. Concordia, Just One, Twilight Imperium, Terraforming Mars, Splendor, Ticket to Ride, Brass Birmingham, Parks, Viticulture, Scythe, Love Letter, Star Wars Rebellion, Carcassonne, Istanbul, Dont mess with Cthulhu, Spirit Island, Sleeping Gods, Onitama, Res Arcana, Hive….Thats the fast selection without thought but immediately after viewing yours which will provoke confirmation and recollection bias. PS Fantastic thing to do….now to the collection to only 10 then 5 then 3!!! That would be a nice FU.

  13. damn, the everdell tokens look edible as heck. wanna eat the forbidden candies

  14. SPOILER ALERT: Here's the complete list:
    @1:15: Favorite Game of All Time: Spirit Island
    @2:08: Engine Builder: Terraforming Mars
    @3:18: For Playing with Your Scumbag Friends: Battlestar Galactica
    @4:32: Easier Co-operative Game: Thunderbirds
    @6:13: 2-Player War Game: Star Wars Rebellion
    @7:50: Sentimental Favorite with Replay-ability: Arkham Horror 2nd Ed.
    @9:38: Similar Space as Arkham Horror, but Different: Arkham Horror – The Card Game
    @11:13: Significant Other's Favorite Game: Obsession
    @12:22: Favorite Abstract Game: Azul
    @13:25: Popular Favorite: Brass Birmingham
    @14:47: Dungeon Crawler: Imperial Assault
    @16:17: Simple Abstract: Santorini
    @17:35: Best Actual War Game: Paths of Glory
    @19:23: Whimsical: Junk Art
    @20:53: "Event" Game for a Special Occasion: Dune (2019)
    @21:57: Game for Everyone: Sushi Go Party!
    @23:17: Space Exploration: Leaving Earth
    @24:55: Light Co-operative Game: The Crew – Mission Deep Sea
    @26:27: Worker Placement and Adorable Animals: Everdell
    @28:02: Deck Building that's also Dudes on a Map: Tyrants of the Underdark

  15. I'd pick 20 games with the biggest boxes possible, pour out their contents and fill them with 100 games…. 🤣

  16. Although I own only 28 games, here is My personal list (I include all expansions I own as part of any individual game)
    7 wonders, Ark Nova, captain sonar, carcassone, cascadia, clank, cosmic encounter, cribbage, dominion, dune imperium, lotr lcg, the resistance, root, tapestry, terraforming mars, terraforming mars: ares expedition, through the ages, QE, twilight imperium (don’t own it but i know id love it) welcome to…

  17. I like how you included games that are excluded by choosing a game to preempt the questions in the comments like "what about this game?" 😊 great collection!

  18. The way I'm thinning my collection is by taking games into my board games club in school. My collection at home gradually shrinks to mine and my wife's favourite games 😊 great video. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

  19. 1. Brass Birmingham
    2. Lord of the Rings LCG
    3. Power Grid
    4. Wingspan
    5. Terraforming Mars
    6. The Game
    7. Nemesis
    8. Decrypto
    9. Spirit Island
    10. Rummikub
    11. Inis
    12. Avalon
    13. Race for the Galaxy
    14. Ticket to Ride Europe
    15. Twilight Imperium 4th Ed
    16. Terraforming Mars
    17. Terra Mystica
    18. Survive!
    19. Clank!
    20. 6 Nimmt

  20. I am still angry for not getting Thunderbirds in a sale for 25€. Now it is so hard to get. No Twilight Imperium? It is so special that I‘d make a 20 + 1 list nit to have to get rid of it.

  21. With you on:
    Sushi Go Party
    Santorini
    Tyrants of the Underdark
    Spirit Island
    Everdell

    Would have included instead:
    Guards of Altantis 2 – If this isn't the best strategic team game in existence, I will eat my hat. It's amazing as a team game, and you can even have a cutthroat and thinking two-player head to head game if you want to.

    Rising Sun – Phenomenal area control game that also brings in diplomacy, bluffing and a side order of betrayal. Fabulous

    Feed the Kraken – absolutely superb social deception that doesn't take hours and hours

    Alchemists – A glorious logic puzzle is at the heart of this euro, and it's a delight to play every single time

    Massive Darkness 2 – A rollicking time of a highly accessible and fun dungeon crawl that will have you taking out monsters and looting to your heart's content until the early hours of the morning.

    Captain Sonar – A frenetic group party experience. Enough said.

    Bullet – competitive or co-op, with optional real-time elements, wrapped in a puzzly game that's easy to understand. Great.

    Edge of Darkness – For pure "deckbuilders" – this one gets my pick due to the multitude of options available to mix and match, and the way that making cards "better" can also end up making them "worse" if they happen to get drawn onto the joint adverserial "tower" that looms over the board.

    Concordia – It's just a deliciously elegant design

    Gugong – A great worker placement and resource management game that is gorgeous to boot.

    Aaaaand I think I can even leave it there with a limit of 15 games!

  22. Anachrony
    Ark Nova
    Civilization New Dawn
    Clank Catacombs
    Dead of Winter
    Fallout
    Fantasy Realms Deluxe
    Firefly
    Lords of Waterdeep
    Lovecraft Letter
    Nemesis
    Raiders of Scythia
    Scythe
    Spirit Island
    Star Wars Rebellion
    Sushi Go
    Talisman 4th Edition
    Terraforming Mars
    Tiny Epic Galaxies
    Wingspan

  23. Great interesting list, thank you.
    This just goes to show, how vast and accommodating to various tastes a boardgame world is: due to my main gaming group’s preferences I can’t fathom an “essential 20” without a hidden movement and a push-your-luck game.

  24. You might be comfortable with the number of games you have, but think of the trees that die to hold them all up. Think of the trees!!

  25. I love Everdell with spirecrest. It fills out the most boring part of the game and adds juice to it.

  26. Have you take a look into High Frontier 4 All? It's the perfect niche game for space colonization / space travel enthusiasts. It's a very complex game but no game made me feel smart like this one. The feeling of grandiosity to prepare a mission (much like Living Earth) and to follow the long journey of our spacecraft on the gigantic map of the solar system, is so engaging.

    The game takes place during our era with technologies that exist or that have been theorized, so we really project ourselves into a future that might be attainable one day. The game uzes theme with schematics and real technical drawings of rocket components, a realistic map of the solar system with real trajectories. With extensions, it covers space exploration (fuel, timing, hazards, racing, rescues, cargo and logistics), star colonization (colonies, space manufacturing, refueling, space stations, resource mining) , the economy based on space metals (resource control, auctions for rocket components, negotiations, engine building), contracts and objectives, epic projects and goals of humanity (exit from the solar system, construction of a dyson sphere, or a generational interstellar ship…), war (the game can turn into a wargame with betrayal, alliances, space and land battles), politics (influence scoring, bend the rules and restrictions to your advantage).

    Can be played solo (great solo game!) and up to 6 (3 best), co-op or competitive. From 4h game time (basic game) to 7h (all extensions). Have 3 level of rules: Basic (almost a family game), medium (most of the rules, but still accessible) and full speed with all the details (radiation, dangers, details rocket components…)
    A one of a kind experience.

  27. The best thing about Imperial Assault is now you don't need a Gamesmaster with the new Commander 2 app

  28. My list would include: Ankh (dudes on map plus fab card strategy), Targi (small box, so smooth to play, deep enough), Segikahara (my war game, with hidden movement on top), Innovation (Civ plus combos, wild but thinky), Radlands and Keyforge (2 player battlers, one is the ultimate, the other in-a-box), Paris La Cite de La Lumiere (the perfect polynomial game where the polynomial mechanic is actually thematic, and so cut-throat for such a pretty game), Pax Porfiriana / Pamir 2nd Ed (economics, politics, and so very clever), Tigris & Euphrates (the best area control game bar none, a classic that twists the area majority mechanic to new heights)…. Sorry can’t get to 20 in a chat window, lol!

  29. Great stuff. I think about a list like this for myself quite often.

    Twilight Imperium
    War Of The Ring
    Hansa Teutonica
    Yinsh
    Freedom: Underground Railroad
    Brass Birmingham
    Catan: Starfarers
    Letters From Whitechapel
    Clash Of Cultures: Monumental Edition
    Imperial
    Fleet: The Dice Game
    1175: Rebellion
    Eclipse
    Champions Of Midgard
    Clockwork Wars
    The Grizzled
    Viticulture
    No Thanks
    Camel Up
    Nations: The Dice Game

  30. Santorini is very cool with the basic game but it rapidly becomes boring I have found. After ten or so rounds it is simply the same thing over and over. Adding in the god powers radically changed the gameplay asymmetrically making every game different. My son and I tend to pull gods at random to play.

  31. Santorini hasn't been hitting the table lately, I suspect because it's enormous compared to tighter 2p games like Onitama and Hive, but it's one of the first (smallish) modern board games I got properly into and holds a special place in my heart. I do think that the golden fleece in the expansion is an excellent idea for playing a balanced and even more positional game and may even be my preferred game mode.

    I totally agree with your take on the Pantheon edition and solo/co-op Riddle of the Sphinx expansion. "Why do this?" Based on the price point and thoughtlessness of ROTS, I think it was a cash grab. I would have liked the more balanced god powers and prettier pieces, but it just wasn't worth ~80USD (IIRC) to me, plus expensive shipping to Canada.

    Maybe if it makes it onto a FLGS shelf for 50CAD I'll think about it, but even then it doesn't seem to add enough, especially if my groups don't play that one often.

    Thank you for the video, it was a very interesting list and has made me add games to my to-play list, which I hope to do at a board game café. I did take some slight offense to Nemesis being cut out due to BS:G, but that's mostly because I can pull Nemesis Co-op mode out with any group of people for an utterly incredible narrative and thematic experience that everyone can enjoy if they don't mind the time-to-play, so I don't usually think about it as a hidden identities/betrayal game.

  32. 1. Wingspan
    2. Terraforming Mars
    3. Everdell
    4. Pan Am
    5. Parks
    6. Dixit
    7. Love Letter
    8. Just One
    9. Splendor
    10. Azul
    11. Pandemic
    12. 7 Wonders
    13. Welcome To
    14. Rolling Realms
    15. Ticket to Ride Europe
    16. Little Prince Make Me a Planet
    17. Harry Potter Hogwarts Battle
    18. Star Trek Missions
    19. Similo
    20. The Crew

  33. Nice to hear your reasoning for each choice, and to see what that choice forced out as well. Really well done.

    My 20 as at this moment of time, bearing in mind I am a solo player who enjoys playing multi-handed where no solo mode exists (and sometimes even when it does).

    Small footprint
    1. Pocket Landship (free trial version) – is a PNP on BGG.
    2. Rollway Station – is also a free PNP on BGG
    3. Volfyirion
    4. Knightmare Chess (requires a chess set obviously) – this is the only one I haven't soloed but it is so bonkers I just have to keep it for the odd occasion someone wants to play.

    Larger footprint – thinky games that won't hurt your head too much
    5. Wingspan
    6. Fields of Green
    7. Alubari – A Nice Cup of Tea
    8. Expedition: Northwest Passage
    9. Silverton
    10. CO2 (First Edition)
    11. Obsession
    12. Nusfjord

    Brain burners – to me anyway
    13. Leaving Earth
    14. Yokohama
    15. Pax Pamir
    16. Labyrinth – The War on Terror

    Table hogs – most have been acquired fairly recently and are currently unplayed but I really want to have the time and space to get into them.
    17. Great Wall – I have played this one
    18. Middara
    19. Xia – Legends of a Drift System
    20. Hegemony

  34. Great video as always! It could be fun to do some "perfect collection" based on space restrictions. Since, usually the most frequent storage solution is Ikea Kallax-style bookshelves it would be fun to try to restrict yourself in a 2×2, 2×4 and 4×4 shelves 😅

  35. great video, loved the format. Not everyone is lucky enough to have an expansive collection. 20 seems like a more achievable-sized collection.

  36. One of the reasons I love your content is that you always provide options for those who want them. This is so good to see that although you like Everdell most, there are several games you could recommend for those who for some reason do not like it or cannot get it.

  37. Tough one, but probably:

    1. Xia
    2. Agricola
    3. Pandemic Clone Wars
    4. Star Wars Armada
    5. Sushi go party
    6. Tichu
    7. Glen More II
    8. Fields of Fire
    9. Fire at the Lake
    10. Enemy Action Ardennes
    11. Distilled
    12. Tiny Epic Dungeons
    13. Isle of Cats
    14. Dead of Winter – Long Night
    15. Wingspan
    16. Imperial Assault
    17. Xenoshyft Dreadmire
    18. Wizards
    19. Nemesis
    20. Clash of Cultures

    No particular order…

  38. Leaving Earth is my favorite game of all time and how I found your channel. I actually clicked on this video solely to see if you'd chosen it for this list because NOTHING scratches that same itch. Cannot recommend it enough to anyone it sounds interesting to.

  39. That's a great list!
    Mine is probably something like this at the moment in no particular order:
    20. Heat
    19. The Game
    18. Scout
    17. Ra
    16. The Thing: The Board Game
    15. Kanban EV
    14. War of the Ring
    13. War Chest
    12. Tigris & Euphrates
    11. Clank! Catacombs
    10. Castles of Burgundy
    9. Fields of Arle
    8. Feast for Odin
    7. Whitehall Mystery
    6. Food Chain Magnate
    5. Concordia
    4. Barrage
    3. Bohnanza
    2. Carcassonne
    1. La Granja

  40. Such a good list. So much overlap with some of my favourite games, that I’ve added several to my “buy list”. Here are my 20 (note: Santorini, War of the Ring, Star Wars Rebellion, and Mage Knight will likely join the list once I get them):

    1. Spirit Island
    2. Through the Ages
    3. Brass: Birmingham
    4. Terraforming Mars
    5. Dune: Imperium
    6. Dominion
    7. Klask
    8. Azul
    9. Everdell
    10. Race for the Galaxy
    11. Agricola
    12. The Crew: Mission Deep Sea
    13. Cascadia
    14. Robinson Crusoe
    15. Cockroach Poker Royal
    16. Go
    17. Lost Ruins of Arnak
    18. 7 Wonders Duel
    19. Wingspan
    20. Carcassonne

  41. Excellent video and excellent presentation! I have always liked your videos and your friendly attitude towards the people. I have 34 games in my collection so I made a list of 15 games which I would keep if forced to keep less games.

    6 nimmt!
    Azul
    Battle Line
    Commands & Colors: Ancients
    Conan
    Crusaders: Thy Will Be Done
    Dominant Species
    Eldritch Horror
    Endeavor: Age of Sail
    Hokkaido
    Kemet
    Lords of Waterdeep
    Marvel United
    Nemesis
    Nidavellir

  42. In alphabetical order:

    1. Andean Abyss – first COIN I've played

    2. Brass Birmingham & Lancashire – only played Lancashire and never won but love it so much I am 100% convinced I will love Birmingham as well

    3. Cartographers – my wife enjoys it a lot and my bad drawing makes it fun for me as well

    4. Catharsis – surprisingly good, although I only have 2 plays so far

    5. Eldritch Horror – I hate it, it frustrates me so much.. and I've only won until I found out how wrong was I calculating how many dice should be thrown.. have everything and will probably keep it forever :D.. for the times when I am too happy for my own good

    6. Escape Plan – just a great game

    7. Forbidden Stars – played only once with 4 people. We didn't finish the game, gave up on the 4th hour. I have a spanish copy and I put translations in the card sleeves :D. I also have 2 big fan expansions, waiting on the third to be finalized and someone to make it available as a groul order or something. Not sure if I'll ever get the group to regularly play it but I adore the design so much.. I also love the 40k universe. Also waiting on the Redux.. hopefully the IP will be good.

    8. Infinity – a bit too complicated and I don't enjoy metal minis (I don't paint so that's partly the reason). Love the universe, love the reaction system and I have the N4 and Code One rulebooks. I have every intention to start playing regularly with my wife and with 40k/Necromunda proxies, we'll see how playable it is this way.

    9. It's a Wonderful Kingdom – didn't look like something I'd enjoy at first. How wrong was I..

    10. Kingdom Death: Monster – have not played much as I got it relatively recently. I like the boss battler genre a lot, Oatshworn was great, Vagrantsong is nice, I liked the Dark Souls and Monster Hunter World boss battles. Oathsworn was a one time experience for me and I passed it along. I added KDM in this list for 2 reasons – I played a couple of games and I enjoyed them a lot. The universe is brutal and I like this kind of fantasy horror. I do not think it is the best boss battler out there however. I am almost completely sure that Aeon Trespass will be better. I just have not tried it so I am putting the one I have.

    11. Leaving Earth – really nice game. Looking forward to the next game from Joe Fatula. I believe it was Moon Landing related.

    12. Letters from Whitechappel – all time favourite for me and my wife. I think I win quite a bit more than her but we still enjoy it. I bought and tried pretty much all hidden movement games I could find just because we loved LfW. It is still the best for us from the ones we tried, but we do have quite a few waiting for table time so it may get replaced as best hidden movement game ever at some point.

    13. Mage Knight – pretty awesome design

    14. Nemesis – really enjoyable I think but I need a bigger group to actually enjoy it

    15. Rococo – very nice game and the deluxe edition looks awesome

    16. SHASN – unexpectedly good and very nice looking game. Looking forward to Azadi.

    17. Spirit Island – needs more plays but based on 2 plays I knoe it is good enough for me to put it in this list

    18. Star Wars Rebellion – very enjoyable. Probably would have enjoyed it even more if it was slightly shorter.

    19. Twisted Fables – I've seen people say it is not very well balanced. No issue for me and my wife thought, we just enjoy the design (both game and graphic). Probably our favourite card game right now.

    20. Watergate – short and engaging

    Additional notes:

    1. Would love to try the Pax games and I think at least one of them would get a spot in the list. I know about the controversies around their designer, but I just ignore his essays and enjoy the game design (played a few of his games, not the pax games though, they are still waiting on my shelf)

    2. Android Netrunner/Nisei, Star Wars LCG and Arkham Horror LCG have a chance od entering the list. Love the universes and the games seem to be very interesting in mechanics. Only played Arkham Horror LCG of them and haven't decided yet if I like it that much or not

  43. I'm new to board gaming, and my goal is to have a collection of 10 to 20 games that I would rank a 9 or 10 out of 10.
    So far I have
    Welcome to the dungeon
    Captain sonar
    Wits and wagers
    Quacks of quedlinburg
    Clank catacombs
    Paperback
    Search for planet x

    I also have but am thinking of getting rid of,
    Quest for eldorado
    Downforce
    Sushi go party
    Not that these games are bad but I'd rather be playing one of the other games.
    I don't play games often enough to get tired of a 20 game collection.

  44. And of course this is the perfect collection for me, and only me, at this particular moment in time. That's for any of the dullards out there who take exception to the title because i didn't include their favourite. But the fun thing with this video is to do the list yourself instead of saying why mine sucks. Tell me why your rules!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.